What a Hypocrite: New Mexico Republican Governor Susana Martinez
SANTA FE, NM (AP) September 9, 2011
New
Mexico Republican Gov. Susana Martinez, who has drawn national attention and
criticism from immigrant groups for trying to stop undocumented immigrants from
getting driver's licenses, has acknowledged her paternal grandparents came to
the U.S. undocumented.
"I know they arrived without documents, especially my father's father," the
Republican said Wednesday in an interview in Spanish with KLUZ-TV, the
Albuquerque Univision affiliate.
Reports about Martinez's grandfather coming across the border undocumented have
surfaced numerous times over the past few years.
The governor's office has largely dodged directly answering questions about the
issue, saying Martinez was unsure of his status since he abandoned the family
when her father was young.
Her comments Wednesday appeared to be the first time she has answered the
question definitively.
Martinez spokesman Scott Darnell confirmed the news Thursday in an interview
with The Associated Press, saying media reports citing U.S. Census data from
1930 showed Martinez's grandparents entered the country undocumented.
"The governor has no information to the contrary," Darnell said. "Neither the
governor, nor her father, had a relationship with her grandfather. She never met
him and didn't know him. He abandoned her father when her father was about five
years old, leaving her father to be raised by extended family."
Martinez has made headlines for her push to repeal a state law that lets
undocumented immigrants get a New Mexico driver's license. She has added the
issue to the agenda for a special session on redistricting that opened Tuesday.
New Mexico is one of only three states – the others are Washington and Utah –
where an undocumented immigrant can get a driver's license because no proof of
citizenship is required.
In protests this week in Santa Fe, advocates and some religious leaders cited
Martinez's family history as a reason the governor should drop her effort to
repeal the driver's license law.
Martinez grew up in El Paso and is the nation's first elected Latina governor.
She has called the issue around her family's immigrant past irrelevant, arguing
immigration laws were different when her grandfather came from Mexico in the
1920s.
But Guadalupe San Miguel Jr., an author and University of Houston history
professor, said immigration laws during the time Martinez says her grandparents
came to the United States weren't much different than they are now.
Those coming to the U.S. were subjected to a number of requirements if they
wanted to stay legally, he said.
"What was different then was the lack of enforcement," San Miguel said. "The
border patrol was created in 1917, and there were just a handful of border
patrol agents. There was no way they could enforce the law."
San Miguel said because of the lack of enforcement Mexican immigrants and
Mexican Americans went back of forth between Mexico and the United States with
little problems.
Lisa Y. Ramos, a Texas A&M University history professor, said most
multigenerational Mexican Americans like Martinez have "at least one family
member with an undocumented past" due to that free range of movement along the
border in early part of the 20th century.
"But Mexican Americans weren't the only ones who have this undocumented past,"
said Ramos, who is writing a book on the Mexican-American civil rights movement.
"A lot of other multigenerational Americans do, too, like Italian Americans."
In fact, then-Sen. Pete Domenici, R-N.M., acknowledged in 2007 during a debate
over a failed immigration bill that his mother was an undocumented immigrant
from Italy and was briefly detained by federal agents during World War II when
he was a child. She eventually became a U.S. citizen.
But Ramos said the irony about Martinez's past is that she might not be governor
of New Mexico today if her grandparents hadn't made the decision to enter the
U.S. the way they did, when they did.
"She wouldn't be there if her grandfather, who was undocumented, hadn't come,"
Ramos said.










