With widespread attention
focused on Arizona's tough
new law against illegal
immigration and a measure
approved this week in the
small town of Fremont, Neb.
similar proposals are
under consideration across
the country.
Five states South
Carolina, Minnesota,
Pennsylvania, Rhode Island
and Michigan are looking
at Arizona-style
legislation, according to
the National Conference of
State Legislatures. NDN, a
Washington think tank and
advocacy group, said
lawmakers in 17 other states
had expressed support for
similar measures.
Since it was adopted in
April, the Arizona
legislation, which gives law
enforcement officers the
power to check the
immigration status of anyone
suspected of being in the
country illegally, has
triggered bitter debate and
been challenged in court by
advocacy groups. Secretary
of State Hillary Rodham
Clinton said last week that
the Justice Department plans
to sue Arizona over the law,
although a department
spokesman has said the
matter is under review.
This week, the spotlight
shifted to rural Fremont,
which narrowly passed an
ordinance that would outlaw
hiring illegal immigrants or
renting property to them.
In the first three months of
this year, legislators in 45
states introduced 1,180
bills or resolutions dealing
with immigrants, an
unprecedented number,
according to the NCSL. By
the end of March, 107 laws
and 87 resolutions had been
adopted by 34 states, with
38 bills pending. Not all of
the proposals were designed
to clamp down on illegal
immigrants. Ann Morse,
director of the Immigrant
Policy Project at the NCSL,
said they represented "a
spectrum" of pro- and
anti-immigration measures.
"The big, overriding issue
for nearly every state is
the state of their budgets,"
said Morse. "Taking on
additional law enforcement
costs and court challenge
costs is not at the front of
their task list."
"When I talk to legislators
about what they're doing in
the state, they say this is
their way of signaling they
want federal immigration
reform to happen that they
care deeply about the issue,
they're working within the
parameters they have and
sometimes at the edge,
trying to get federal
attention," she said.
Last month, the
Massachusetts Senate amended
its budget bill to require
state contractors to confirm
that their workers are in
the country legally.
Earlier, the Massachusetts
House narrowly rejected a
proposal to restrict public
benefits to illegal
immigrants.
In Pennsylvania, an
Arizona-style bill is in the
pipeline. Although police
officers must have a
separate reason to stop
someone, the proposal would
direct them to "attempt to
verify the immigration
status of suspected illegal
aliens."
South Carolina is set to
discuss an almost identical
measure next year. And in
Albuquerque, Mayor Richard
Berry instituted a similar
policy, which was upheld by
a council vote.
Anti-illegal immigrant
measures in Hazelton, Pa.,
and Farmers Branch, Tex.,
are being challenged in the
courts.
In Fremont, those on both
sides agreed that the town's
new ordinance, which will
take effect in July, marked
a national pattern of local
communities taking
immigration policy into
their own hands.
"I'm afraid this is part of
a larger, nationwide trend,
most obviously typified by
what has happened in
Arizona," said Amy Miller,
the legal director of the
American Civil Liberties
Union in Nebraska, which is
seeking an injunction
against the Fremont law.
"There is no rational reason
for Fremont to be worried
about protecting our border.
But it is a community, like
many in rural Nebraska,
where the only population
growth has been in new
immigrants, many of them
people of color."
"What will this lead to?
Other municipalities in
other states enacting their
own laws," said Fremont
council member Sean Gitt,
who said he decided to
support the measure after it
was approved by the
community.
"Fremont is an example of
'If Washington won't,
Nebraskans will,' " said Bob
Dane, spokesman for the
Federation for American
Immigration Reform, which
supports tougher immigration
enforcement. Others note
that the economy may
determine whether other
jurisdictions follow
Arizona's lead.