Hispanics going from Farm Workers to Farm Owners
SANTA
FE, NM
(By
Judy
O'Meara,
The Jon Garrido Network)
February
28, 2011
―
I
recently
started
a series
of
articles
about
the New
Mexico
Santa Fe
Farmers’
Market
and
their
many
vendors.
In the
midst of
this
exploration,
I have
found an
exciting
correlative
issue
worth
mentioning.
A
progressive
migratory
change
or
paradigm
shift is
taking
place.
As
reported
in the
U.S.
Department
of
Agriculture-2007
Census,
Hispanics
claim
the
highest
rate of
new
farmers
in the
nation.
Out of
66,671
farms
and
ranches
there
were a
total of
82,462
Hispanics
operators
across
the
United
States.
The
number
of
Hispanic
operators
grew 14
percent
from
2002,
significantly
out
pacing
the 7
percent
increase
of U. S.
farm
operators
overall.
A total
of
55,570
U. S.
farms
had a
principal
operator
of
Spanish,
Hispanic
or
Latino
(*)
origin
in 2007.
Up from
50,592
in 2002
an
increase
of 10
percent.
Texas,
New
Mexico
and the
Pacific
Coast
states
saw the
largest
increases
in
Hispanic
or
Latino
farm
operators
from
2002 to
2007.
Overall,
the
percentage
of
Hispanics
principal
operators
is
highest
in the
Western
United
States
with New
Mexico
(30.9
percent),
California
(11.3
percent),
Texas
(8.2
percent),
Florida
(6.7
percent)
and
Hawaii
(5.9
percent).
Tirso
Moreno,
general
coordinator
for the
Farm
worker
Association
of
Florida
has also
seen
similar
growth
in the
past
decade.
According
to him
"Florida
has more
than
3,100
farms
and
agriculture-related
business
where
Hispanics
are the
principal
operators,
making
up
almost 7
percent
of the
47,500
total.
Many
immigrant
families,
especially
from
Central
America
and
Mexico,
have
strong
farming
roots,
which
likely
has
contributed
to the
increase
in
Hispanic
&
Latino
population
and the
increase
in
Hispanic-owned
farms".
What has
happened
in many
places
across
the U.S., the
predominately
white
farm
owners/operators
are
reaching
retirement
age and
selling
their
businesses.
Their
children
have no
interest
in
staying
on the
family
farm.
This has
opened a
great
opportunity
for
Hispanic/Latino
immigrants
and farm
hands.
As
revealed
by the
2007
Census
"Hispanic
or
Latino
principal
farm
operators
themselves
are
predominantly
male,
however;
the
total of
female
farm
operators
of
Hispanic
or
Latino
origin
grew 20
percent
from
2002.
Women
now
comprise
12
percent
of
Hispanic
or
Latino
operators,
up from
10
percent
in 2002.
The
average
Hispanic
or
Latino
farmer
has only
been on
his
present
farm for
4 years
or less,
which
substantiates
the
recent
shift
from
farm
hand to
farm
owner.
Out of
29
states
the
Hispanic
or
Latino
operator/farmer
comprises
less
than 1
percent
and are
more
likely
to want
to own
all the
land
that
they
operate.
Keeping
the
smaller-owned
farm
financially
afloat
requires
working
at least
some
days in
an
off-farm
job. In
addition,
pressures
from
corporate
farms
and the
issue of
farm
subsidies
and
agriculture
legislation
to come
are
front
and
center
for more
and more
Latinos.
More
than
one-third
of all
Hispanic-operated
farms or
ranches
is
classified
as beef
cattle
operations.
Another
16
percent
are
classified
as fruit
and nut
farms,
compared
to 4
percent
of farms
overall.
And
while 15
percent
of farms
overall
are
classified
as grain
and
oilseed
farms,
only 3
percent
of
Hispanic-operated
farms
fall
into
this
category."
Much of
the same
information
is found
in the
article
written
by
Eloisa
Ruano
Gonzalez
published
in the
Orlando
Sentinel,
"Hispanics
going
from
field
hand to
farm
owner."
"Most of
the
Hispanic
farmers
in
Florida
own
small
ferneries
or
nurseries
or are
growing
fruits
and
vegetables,
such as
tomatoes.
The new
Hispanic
farm
owner is
most
likely a
child of
Mexican
immigrants.
This is
true of
Benito
Baca and
Tony
Ramos of
Pierson,
FL. They
are now
among a
growing
number
of
Hispanics
in the
U.S. who
have
gone
from
field
hand to
farm
operator.
Work has
not been
a
stranger
to these
two.
From age
5, they
worked
after
school
cutting
foliage
used in
flower
bouquets.
If one
fell
behind
cutting
leaves,
the
other
pitched
in so
they
could
make
baseball
practice.
It looks
like all
the hard
work has
paid
off.
Benito
Baca
started
a
business
presumably
in 2009
setting
up
irrigation
systems
at local
nurseries
and
subdivisions.
Tony
Ramos
has a
small
nursery
started
in 2005,
where he
sells
hedges
and
shrubs
to
wholesalers
and
landscaping
companies."
Financial
funding
is a
major
problem
facing
the new
Hispanic
or
Latino
owner.
As
revealed
by Dr. Mickie
Swisher,
Director
of the
University
of
Florida’s
Center
for
Organic
Agriculture
when she
conducted
a study
for the
USDA on
small-scale
Hispanic
farmers
and
ranchers
and
their
needs.
The
study
focused
on
California,
Florida,
New
Mexico,
Texas
and
Puerto
Rico,
which
have the
highest
number
of
Hispanic
farmers.
Swisher
says
"While
the
farmers
were
mostly
second-generation
Hispanics
and
spoke
English,
they
were
unaware
of
grants
and
other
government
resources
available.
This was
exactly
the case
for
Benito
Baca and
Tony
Ramos.
Benito
Baca
raided
his
savings
and
maxed
out his
credit
cards to
launch
his
irrigation
business.
Tony
Ramos
got
private
bank
loans to
start
his
nursery
business,
on 2
acres
owned by
his
father.
His
nursery
has
doubled
to 4
acres.
Ramos,
who has
a
political-science
degree
from
Stetson
University
in
DeLand,
Fla.,
had been
working
for a
Bunnell,
Fla.,
nursery
when he
saw an
opportunity
to start
his own.
Even
while
running
his own,
Ramos
kept
working
at the
Bunnell
nursery,
owned by
a local
family,
until it
closed
last
year."
Dr.Swisher’s
areas of
interest
and
expertise
are in
rural
development
in both
the
United
States
and
internationally.
Her
experience
includes
six
years
working
with
farmers
and
their
communities
in North
Central
Florida
and 15
years of
experience
with the
Florida
Cooperative
Extension
Service.
According
to
Swisher,
"There
are
people
out
there
like her
friend
Rudy
Arredondo,
president
of the
National
Latino
Farmers
and
Ranchers
Association,
who is
working
with
grants
and
other
government
resources.
His
decade
old
organization,
started
after
the
nation’s
number
of
Hispanic
farmers
jumped
by 52
percent,
is
trying
to
change
that. He
helped
write
the 2008
Farm
Bill,
which
added
money
for
outreach
and
grant
and loan
programs
for
minority
farmers.
In
November,
the USDA
awarded
his
association
a grant
for more
than
$300,000
to
improve
Hispanics’
access
to
federal
programs
and help
them
succeed."
Both
Swisher
and
Arredondo
both
concur,
the
Federal
government
has not
done a
good job
informing
Hispanic
about
farm
loans,
crop
insurance
and
other
resources
that
help
start,
expand
or keep
their
businesses
afloat.
There
are many
programs
available
like the
Hispanic
American
Outreach
Program
run by
the USDA
Farm
Service
Agency
to help
farmers
and
ranchers
with
disaster
recovery
and loan
opportunities.
The
Federal
government
offers
grants
and
loans
for
minority
and
beginning
farmers.
For
example,
minority
farmers
can
apply
for up
to
$200,000
through
the U.S.
Department
of
Agriculture's
Small,
Socially-Disadvantaged
Producer
Grant.
The
USDA's
Farm
Service
Agency
also
offers
low-interest-rate
loans to
beginning
farmers
who
cannot
find
financing
from
commercial
lenders.
Getting
the word
out to
the
Hispanic
or
Latino
farmer
seems to
be a
major
problem.
Even
though
they can
now
speak
English,
most do
not have
computers,
many
government
forms
are
difficult
for the
average
person
to
complete
and the
communicating
with
government
employees
as well
as
finding
the time
away
from the
day-to-day
operations
is
almost
impossible.
Swisher
further
indicates,
"Hispanics
are
playing
an
important
role in
strengthening
and
diversifying
the
country’s
farm
sector.
They are
providing
American
consumers
with
alternatives
to
mega-supermarkets
and
fueling
food
cooperatives,
community-supported
farms
and
farmers’
market.
It’s
part of
the
American
tradition,
having
many
choices.
They
have
introduced
new
fruits
and
vegetables
to the
U. S.
market.
For
example,
Hispanic
and
Caribbean
farmers
provide
red
turnips
and
different
varieties
of chili
peppers
and
greens.
Studies
have
also
proven
water
and soil
conservation
improves
greatly
when
small
family
farmers
work the
land."
We
sometimes
conveniently
forget
there is
a
shortage
of farm
workers
in the
U. S.
Hispanic
or
Latino
farmers
are
helping
to fill
the gap
even
though
out of
29
states
they
only
represent
1
percent
of the
farm
operators.
A recent
article
from the
New York
Times
reveals,
"Upstate
farms
are
suffering
because
very few
U.S. ―
born
citizens
will
accept
agriculture
jobs ―
and the
undocumented
workers
who have
been
staffing
them for
years
are
being
hounded
out by
anti-immigration
zeal. As
a
result,
farmers
are
scaling
back
production
of
labor-intensive
fruit
and
vegetable
crops
and
investing
heavily
in
labor-replacing
machinery.
Substituting
human
labor
with
machinery
not only
boost
agriculture's
fossil
fuel
use, it
also
makes
farms
more
vulnerable
by
strapping
them
with
debt.
Not
surprisingly,
their
lenders
are
getting
nervous.
As
revealed
before
the U.S.
House
Agriculture
Committee
by an
official
from
Farm
Credit
of
Western
New
York,
more
than 800
farms in
the
state,
representing
750,000
acres in
farmland,
were
highly
vulnerable
to going
out of
business
or
forced
to
become
part-time
farms
from a
severe
labor
shortage.
These
operations,
whose
average
size is
less
than 100
acres,
essentially
represent
New
York's
base of
mid-sized
farms.
The Farm
Credit
official
predicted
that if
those
farms
fail,
much of
that
land
would
likely
remain
in some
form of
agriculture,
but that
hundreds
of
thousands
of acres
would be
vulnerable
to being
discontinued
from
crop
production
and
converted
to
non-farm
uses. In
other
words,
what's
left of
New
York's
most
productive
farmland
may soon
be
sprouting
second
homes
and
vacation
condos
where it
once
produced
tomatoes
and
green
beans."
As
reported
by Tom
Philpott
in his
article
regarding
creating
a
sustainable
food
system
he
quotes
information
from the
Associated
Press,
"Mexican
farm
workers
are
having
trouble
heading
north
over an
increasingly
well-patrolled
border ― but
U.S.
farm
owners
are
crossing
the
other
way
freely.
Many
U.S.
growers
have
moved
their
fields
to
Mexico,
where
they can
find
qualified
people,
often
with
U.S.
experience,
who
can't be
deported.
When
they
jump the
border
to buy
land ―
presumably
without
having
to risk
their
lives in
the
desert
or hire
"coyotes"
to ease
the
passage
― U.S.
farm
owners
find an
oasis of
cheap
and
compliant
labor.
U.S.
farm
employers
can buy
a whole
day's
worth of
labor
for a
wage
($9.60)
equal to
an
hour's
worth of
work at
the
going
rate
north of
the
border
― while
still
doubling
Mexico's
minimum
wage of
$4.80
per day.
We are
talking
mainly
about
large-scale
agriculture
here
― the
kind
that
keeps
your
local
Wal-Mart
stocked
with
little
bags of
baby
spinach
and
asparagus
all
year. In
the
logic of
industrial
farming
― where
food is
grown in
vast,
centralized
mono
crops,
and then
distributed
in
thousand
mile-plus
radii ―
the
shift
from
California
to
Mexico
makes a
certain
sense.
Mexico
is
closer
to
eastern
U.S.
markets
than
California,
shipping
times to
Atlanta
are a
day
shorter
from
Mexico's
central
Guanajuato
State."
Philpott
adds
"The
labor
crunch
is
surely
also
squeezing
California's
mid
sized
operations
― the
farms
that
will be
needed
to
broaden
local-food
access
in one
of the
nation's
most
economically
stratified
states.
In farm
fields
larger
than
even a
few
acres,
diversified
vegetable
farming
is
extremely
labor
intensive
― and
in the
modern
U.S.,
farm
labor
generally
means
immigrant
labor.
What,
then, is
the
answer?
In the
short
term,
the U.S.
should
end its
ridiculous
immigration
policies.
As I've
written
before,
Mexican
farm
workers
don't
sneak
across
one of
the
globe's
most
militarized
borders
to
freeload
off of
U.S.
taxpayers,
despite
the
fantasies
of
certain
cable-TV
commentators.
Rather,
they're
fleeing
a
near-complete
meltdown
in
small-scale
Mexican
agriculture
― one
that
directly
implicates
the
free-trade
zeal of
U.S.
policymakers
and
corporations.
But even
if U.S.
policymakers
did open
the
border
―
highly
unlikely
― we
can't
build a
sustainable
food
system
in the
United
States
on the
backs of
former
Mexican
farmers
who have
been
driven
off
their
land by
NAFTA
and
other
binational
U.S.-Mexico
policies.
The time
has come
for the
U.S.
sustainable-food
movement
to
develop
a North
American
consciousness
― to
foster a
farm
worker
movement
of its
own, and
to seek
coalitions
with
Mexican
small-farm
advocates
to
rebuild
local
and
regional
food
networks
on both
sides of
the
border.
"
While
there
are many
people
in the
U. S.
who
recent
the
growth
of the
Hispanic
or
Latino
farm
owners,
if they
don’t
try to
support
them,
the big
farm
companies
will
continue
to ship
more of
their
operations
to
Mexico
and
other
near by
countries.
This
could
possibly
result
in much
higher
cost for
our
food.
A study
done in
April
2009 by
the
Department
of Labor
reveals,
out of a
$49,638
family
annual
income,
the
average
annual
expenditure
for food
consumed
at home
is
$3465,
which is
7% and
food
away
from
home is
to
$2558,
which is
5.4%.
Another
study
done by
the USDA
Agriculture
on the
"US
Household
Looking
Ahead to
2020,
Economic
Research
Service
USDA
Agriculture
Report
No.821"
reveals
"Total
food
expenditures
Nation
wide are
projected
to
increase
26.3
percent
between
2000 and
2020.
Food
away-from-home
expenditures
are
projected
to
increase
27.5
percent.
The
largest
projected
increase
in
expenditures
is for
fruits,
up 27.5
percent,
while
the
smallest
is for
both
beef and
nonalcoholic
beverages
up 21.1
percent.
Expenditures
for
meats,
poultry,
fish,
and eggs
are
projected
to
increase
22.8
percent.
Within
this
category
beef
spending
will
increase
21.1
percent
while
fish
will
increase
25.2
percent.
The U.
S.
Census
Bureau
projects
our
population
to
increase
by 50
million
during
this 20
year
period,
which is
clearly
the
biggest
boost to
food
demand
in the
future."
We
should
not
blame
the
Hispanic
or
Latino
farmer
for
this. No
matter
what
origin,
most
only
makes 20
cents
out of
each
dollar.
That is
why
keeping
markets
like the
Santa Fe
Farmers’
Market
going is
so
vitally
important.
Among
other
things,
they
help to
eliminate
the
middleman
and keep
the
smaller
to
mid-sized
farms
afloat
Even
Cardinal
Roger
Mahony,
Roman
Catholic
Archbishop
of Los
Angeles
realizes
the
contribution the
Hispanic
or
Latino
farmer
or
immigrant contributes. "Immigrants
― both
documented
and
undocumented
― are
actually
subsidizing
our
family
food
bills.
These
workers
usually
earn
minimum
wage,
and work
for
staggered
periods
of time.
That's
why in
this
country
we pay
only
9.5% of
our
annual
income
for
food ― the
lowest
percentage
in the
world.
Other
countries
and
their
percentage
of
income
spent
for
food:
United
Kingdom,
11%;
Japan,
17%;
South
Africa,
27%;
India,
53%. In
reflecting
back on
my years
in
ministry
as a
priest
and as a
bishop,
I have
come to
see that
so much
of that
ministry
brought
me in
touch
with
immigrant
peoples,
regardless
of how
they
came to
this
country.
Cardinal
Roger
Mahony
wrote, "While
growing
up in
the San
Fernando
Valley I
came in
contact
with
those
Mexican-American
men and
women
who
worked
for my
parents
at their
plant.
They
became
my
friends.
During
my years
as a
seminarian
at Saint
John’s
Seminary
in
Camarillo,
several
of us
seminarians
were
able to
accompany
priests
to the
farm
labor
camps
where
Mass was
offered
for the
braceros,
the
temporary
farm
workers
mostly
from
Mexico."
Cardinal
Mahony
feels we
need to
acknowledge
the
Hispanic,
Latino
or
Mexican
as our
"neighbors,
co-workers,
students,
and
friends — and
they
contribute
greatly
to our
nation
and to
our
communities.
Instead
of being
side
tracked
by
heated
rhetoric
and
political
posturing,
all of
us
should
take the
time to
open our
minds
and
hearts
to hear
the
actual
stories
of the
immigrants
themselves.
How do
their
experiences
impact
our
local
communities
and our
nation?
Look
into
their
faces.
The more
we come
to know
immigrants
as
individual
people
like
ourselves
with the
same
longings
and
yearnings
for
themselves,
their
families,
and our
countries,
the more
we will
understand
the need
to
reform
federal
immigration
laws to
help
bring
these
people
along a
path to
legal
recognition.
We
forget
Joseph
and Mary
were
immigrants
in
search
of a
safe
place
for
Jesus
who
said,
"Thy
shall
love thy
neighbor
as
thyself."
It
matters
profoundly
what one
believes
but also
important
is our
delicate
ecological
system
and
creating
a
sustainable
food
supply
for
future
demand.
I for
one am
excited
about
the
Hispanic,
Latino
or
Mexican
contribution
in
helping
us
create a
balance
between
the two
systems.
Let us
reach
out to
the new
younger
Hispanic
or
Latino
farm
hand and
recognize
it
takes
courage
to
become a
farm
owner.
Give him
or her
deserving
respect
and
welcome
the
expertise.
---------------------------
(*)
Hispanic
or
Latino
has been
used
within
statistical
information
in this
article.
To
clarify
preference
between
Hispanic
or
Latino,
the
following
is
provided:
Historically,
areas
of the
Americas conquered
by the
Spaniards
were
considered
part of
a region
called
Hispania.
Countries
that
trace
their
history
to Spain
are
considered
Hispanic.
Where
Spanish
is the
primary
language,
these
countries
include:
Mexico,
Central
America,
and most
of South
America.
The
exception
to this
Hispanic
designation
is
Brazil
―
settled
by
Portugal
not by
Spain
―
where
Portuguese
is the
national
language.
People
from
Mexico,
El
Salvador,
Guatemala,
Panama
and
other
areas
south of
the
American
border
would
be
considered
Hispanic.
There is
one other major factor that gives ethnic identity: Spain
conquered
the Americas (the new
world)
and in
doing
so,
devastated
and
plunder
the ancient
civilizations
of the
Aztecs,
Toltecs,
Mayans,
Olmecs,
and
other
people
of
Mesoamerica
that developed
the
first
great
city/states
of the
Americas.
Consequently,
it is
not a
matter
of
location
of
origin
but
rather
how
people
self
identify.
The Jon
Garrido
Network
publishes
Hispanic
News,
the
number 1
ranked
Hispanic
site by
Google,
Yahoo
and
Bing,
in
addition
the
network
publishes
New
Mexico
News,
Latino
News and
Latin
America
News.
Lastly,
The Jon
Garrido
Network
is now
developing
three
websites
that
will
closely
follow
the Facebook
concept: NosostrosUSA.com,
HispSM.com
and
LatSM.com
to
provide
persons
multiple
options
to
choose
from.
---------------------------
I am
indebted
to Jon
Garrido
in
writing
this
article.
Jon
Garrido
is the
former:
executive
director
of
economic
development
for the
City of
El Paso,
Texas,
staff
director
of the
El Paso
Industrial
development
authority,
economic
development
coordinator
for the
City of
Tucson,
Arizona,
community
development
director
for the
Salt
River
Indian
Community
in
Scottsdale,
Arizona
and vice
president
for
planning
and
development
for
Valgroup,
formerly
the
largest
real
estate
development
company
in
Arizona.
Jon
Garrido
is owner
and CEO
of The
Jon
Garrido
Network,
27
websites
which
include
Nosostros
USA, New
Mexico
News,
Latino
News,
Latin
America
News and
Hispanic
News.