Who, Myers asked in his book, "Immigrants and Boomers: Forging a New Social Contract for the Future of America," will fill the skilled jobs held by the millions of retiring baby boomers in the decades ahead? Who will be able to buy their homes?
Myers' answer: For a large percentage of those retirees, their replacements will have to come from among undocumented and their children, the people who will compose the largest part of California's working-age and home-buying population, and an increasing part of the U.S. population as well. At the same time, the sharp decline in the Mexican birthrate of the past generation will slow the growth of that country's labor force and reduce the pressure to emigrate.
In
another
decade
or two,
we may
need
more
people
of
working
and
home-buying
age than
we've
got.
Newly
compiled
census
data on
California
(remember,
as
California
goes so
goes the
USA)
homeownership,
combined
with
recent
economic
and
demographic
reports
from
Mexico
and the
United
States,
confirm
both
points.
Begin
with the
housing
factor.
In a
report
released
this
month,
Myers
shows
the
dramatic
generational
and
ethnic
changes
in
California
homeownership.
As the
number
of
older,
white
homeowners
continued
to
shrink
from the
1980s
through
the
first
decade
of this
century
through
relocation,
entry
into
assisted
living
or
rental
housing,
or death
most
of their
homes
were
bought
not by
younger
whites
but by
Latinos.
In the
2000s,
the
total
number
of what
the
census
calls
non-Hispanic
white
homeowners
in
California
declined
by
nearly
158,000.
In the
same
decade,
even as
the
percentage
of all
Californians
owning
their
own
homes
went
down,
the
number
of
Hispanic
homeowners
in the
state
increased
by
nearly
384,000,
accounting
for more
than 78%
of the
growth
in
California's
homeownership.
As early
as 2005,
Myers
wrote in
"Immigrants
and
Boomers,"
the most
common
surnames
of new
California
home
buyers
were
Garcia,
Hernandez,
Rodriguez,
Lopez
and
Martinez.
Nationwide,
four of
the top
10 names
were
Hispanic.
"It is
young
Hispanic
home
buyers,
and also
Asians,
who have
taken up
the
slack
from
diminished
white
demand,"
Myers
says in
his new
report.
In the
coming
years,
however,
there'll
be even
fewer
whites
to
replace
those
old
homeowners.
"The
clear
challenge
[then]
will be
how to
pick up
the
growing
slack
.
'Who is
going to
buy your
house?'
has
become
an
important
question
for all
of us."
There's
a
related
question,
crucial
for both
California
and the
nation:
Who'll
have the
job
skills
to
replace
those
retiring
boomers
in the
future?
While
media
attention
has been
focused
on the
Mexican
drug
wars and
our own
political
battles
over
immigration,
the big
story
may well
be the
growth
of the
Mexican
economy
and the
increasing
number
of
economic
and
educational
opportunities
it
offers.
In the
last
four
years
the U.S.
population
of
undocumented
immigrants
declined
from
roughly
12
million
to 11
million.
Detentions
of
undocumented
aliens
by the
Border
Patrol
are also
sharply
down.
According
to the
Pew
Hispanic
Center,
the
number
of
undocumented
border-crossers
who
settled
in the
United
States
dropped
from the
annual
average
of
525,000
in the
first
years of
this
century
to fewer
than
100,000
last
year.
Some of
those
changes
are due
to the
economic
troubles
of the
last
four
years;
some may
be due
to
tougher
enforcement
of
immigration
laws.
But some
may also
be
attributable
to the
declining
Mexican
birthrate
and
Mexico's
improving
economy.
The
biggest
issue of
the next
decade
may not
be
closing
the
border
to
undocumented
aliens
but
opening
opportunities,
especially
higher
education,
to
undocumented
and
their
children.
Yet as
boomers
retire
by the
millions
beginning
in this
decade,
taking
their
skills
with
them,
California,
rather
than
making
college
and
other
advanced
education
more
accessible,
is
making
access
harder,
shutting
down
programs
and
increasing
the
costs.
"Cultivating
a
stronger
base of
future
home
buyers,"
Myers
says,
"will
help the
older
generation
as much
as the
young.
This
partnership
needs to
be
strengthened
between
older
future
home
sellers
and
younger
potential
home
buyers."
So far,
however,
the
critical
economic
and
social
nexus
between
the
self-interest
of older
white
homeowners
and the
younger
Hispanics
and
other
undocumented
who
represent
much of
the
state's
future
is
hardly
perceived
by much
of
California's
tax-averse
electorate.
According
to
scholars
such as
Harvard
economist
Alberto
Alesina,
the
greater
the
ethnic
gap
between
voters
and the
perceived
beneficiaries
of
public
goods
education,
social
welfare
and
health
programs
and
other
services
the
more
reluctant
voters
are to
support
the
taxes to
pay for
them.
The
California
of the
1950s
and
1960s,
which
was
overwhelmingly
white
and
middle
class,
generously
provided
for
those
public
goods.
The
California
of the
last
three
decades,
in which
undocumented
and
their
children
have
become
an
increasingly
large
part of
the
population,
has not.
We are
crippling
our own
economic
future.











